All Old Fashioned Candy

Mini Licorice AllsortsMini Licorice Allsorts are the perfect treat for any licorice lover! These firm black licorice pieces come in an assortment of shapes and textures, all in a colorful mini size. Enjoy the classic licorice taste in these bright and...

Old Fashioned Pastel Chocolate StrawsOld Fashioned Pastel Chocolate Straws - Lightweight, crispy shell filled with a smooth chocolatey inside. These chocolate straws come in an assortment of pastel colors. Great old-fashioned Christmas Candy for your...

Mary Jane CandyIndulge in the sweet nostalgia of Mary Jane candy, a timeless taffy treat that has been delighting taste buds for generations. With its unmistakable flavor and unique charm, Mary Jane candy continues to capture the hearts of candy...

Mary Jane Candy Fun SizeThe Mary Jane Candy Fun Size is a delicious twist wrap candy with the perfect blend of Molasses and Peanut Butter flavors. Originally made in 1914 by the Charles N. Miller Company, this candy was named after Charles' favorite...

Long Boys Junior CandyLong Boys Junior Candy is an old-fashioned chewy treat that combines creamy caramel with coconut flakes. Made in the USA, this candy offers a blissful experience with each bite. Each pound of Long Boys Junior Candy includes...

Claey's Hard Candy - SassafrasClaey's Hard Candy - Sassafras is a brightly colored, sugar sanded, hard candy with a delightful sassafras flavor. Transport yourself back in time and indulge in the nostalgic taste of these delicious candies. Similar in...

Old Fashioned Christmas Chocolate StrawsOld Fashioned Christmas Chocolate Straws are a delightful holiday treat that will surely bring back memories of nostalgic Christmases past. These shiny red and green striped chocolate straws are light-weight,...

Old Fashioned Christmas MixStep back in time this holiday season with the delightful \Old Fashioned Christmas Mix\ by Cavalier Candies. This time-honored mix brings the nostalgic joy of classic Christmas celebrations right into your home. Perfect for...

Boston Baked Beans Candy 24 PackBoston Baked Beans 24 pack. Classic candy-coated peanuts. These \Original\ Boston Baked Beans are an old-fashioned candy favorite, with a sweet crunchy candy shell. Each box is 0.8oz, 24 boxes per order.Retro CandyRed...

Ice Cubes Chocolate Candy 100 PieceIce Cubes Chocolate Candy 100 Piece are sweet treats that melts in your mouth. Ice Cubes Candy has a velvety chocolate bite and feels cool to the tongue, making them a unique treat. It’s no wonder they’ve been around...

Boyer Smoothie Cups UnwrappedBoyer Smoothie Cups Unwrapped are a delightful treat that combines the creaminess of peanut butter with the rich flavor of butterscotch. Made by Boyer, a company with a long history of crafting delicious candies, these...

Tart N TinysTart N Tinys A truly nostalgic candy is back! The original tart n’ tinys available in the five original flavors plus new blue raspberry. These are exactly like the original; uncoated, full of flavors, and \stackable\. Grab a handful and...

Tootsie Roll 36 PieceTootsie Roll 36 Piece. Simply large versions of the bite-sized candy we have grown to love. Each bar is 2.25oz. 36 Tootsie Rolls per box.Chewy CandyRetro CandyTootsie RollOld Fashioned CandyGluten Free Candy

Claeys Hard Candy Drops Raspberry 6oz BagClaeys Hard Candy Drops Raspberry 6oz Bag. Old Fashioned Hard Candy Full of Raspberry flavor. Approximately 42 pieces per bag. Made in the USA. Perfect for candy lovers. Order now and satisfy your sweet tooth!Hard...

Old Fashioned Peppermint SticksOld Fashioned Peppermint Sticks bring back the nostalgic joy of Christmas with their festive red and white stripes. These delicious candies have a thin crispy shell that gives way to a creamy mint filling. Each peppermint...