All Old Fashioned Candy

Beemans, Clove, Black Jack, and Teaberry Chewing Gum 20 PackBeemans, Clove, Black Jack, and Teaberry Chewing Gum 20 Pack. That's right, with the reintroduction of Teaberry, we're putting the band back together! Enjoy this amazing assortment of your...

Black Shoestring Licorice Laces 2 PoundsBlack Shoestring Licorice by Gerrit Verburg is a must-have for licorice lovers everywhere. Soft and chewy, these black shoestring licorice laces come in the classic flavor that will bring back memories of going to...

Bonomo Turkish Taffy Chocolate 24 PieceBonomo Turkish Taffy Chocolate 24 Piece. Smack it, crack it, and enjoy this delicious chocolate taffy nostalgic candy. A perfect addition to your next retro candy bar. Each pack contains 24 Bonomo Turkish Taffy bars...

Cashew BrittleCashew Brittle is a delicious candy treat that will satisfy your sweet tooth and leave you craving more. Made by Old Dominion Peanut, a trusted brand since 1913, this buttery toffee candy is a must-have for any candy lover. With its...

Chick O Stick 36 Piece Chick O Stick 36 Piece The old \Chicken Bones\ candy has a new name but the recipe is still the same, these crunchy peanut candies are sprinkled with toasted coconut and come in a 36 count box for your enjoyment! Made in the USA...

Clay's Hard Candy Drops Anise 6oz BagClay's Hard Candy Drops Anise 6oz Bag. Clay's Hard Candy Drops are the perfect choice for those who love old-fashioned hard candies. Bring back the nostalgia with this delicious candy that is full of Anise flavor,...

Fun DipFun Dip - Good old fashioned fun with Fun Dip! A great choice for party treat bags, Easter baskets, and stocking stuffers. Fun Dip contains two flavors Cherry Yum Diddly Dip and Razz Apple Magic Dip. 48 Fun Dip Packs per box.Fun Dip is the perfect...

Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Lemon 80 SticksGilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Lemon 80 sticks are retro candy sticks that bring back memories of old-fashioned penny candy stores. These hard candy sticks have a bold lemon flavor that will tantalize...

Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Strawberry 80 SticksLooking for a taste of nostalgia? Look no further than Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Strawberry! These retro candy sticks will transport you back to the good old days of penny candy stores. Each...

Jujyfruits Theater Box 12 PackJujyfruits Theater Box 12 Pack.  Since the 1920s, candy lovers have been enjoying this chewy fruity candy.  This retro candy classic still comes in all your favorite flavors:  Red Raspberry, Orange, Yellow Lemon, Green...

Mike and Ike Original 24 PackGet your taste of nostalgia with this Rainbow candy. Order now for a sweet treat!The Mike and Ike Original 24 Pack is the perfect choice for candy lovers who want a delicious and chewy treat. The pack includes 24 0.78oz boxes...

Sugar Babies 1.7 oz 24 PackBite-sized, chewy caramel candies coated in a sweet sugary shell are what you can expect from the Sugar Babies. Perfect for candy lovers of all ages, this nostalgic treat offers convenience and flavor in every bite. The...

Razzles Original 24 PackRazzles Original 24 Piece is a unique candy that transforms into gum as you chew. This classic candy first hit the shelves in the mid-60s and has since become a beloved treat for candy enthusiasts of all ages. The brand has...

Sugar Daddy Candy 24 PieceThe Sugar Daddy Candy 24 Piece is a delicious milk caramel pops that will take you back to sweet memories of the past. This classic retro candy is a must-have for any candy lover. Each box contains 24 pieces of the mouthwatering...

Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Cinnamon 80 SticksThe Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Cinnamon is reminiscent of the retro candy sticks found at old-fashioned penny candy stores. Individually wrapped, each beautifully striped hard candy stick...